{"id":1995,"edition":11,"categories":1,"features":0,"size":8526,"name":"Guardian Village","authors":[{"name":"Nights","login":"Nightscratch","gh":105291215}],"description":"

Click on the character to build a collection, barracks, arrow tower hospitals, houses, etc., and strengthen your village

\n","source":"Nightscratch/guardian-village","stars":1,"comments":[{"at":347526699,"author":"Tiago Correia","login":"dosaki","gh":1957450,"url":"https://dosaki.net/","text":"

The controls are a bit clunky. The game looks like it’d be fun with a little more time spent on it - I know you found the competition a bit too late :(

\n

Good effort though!

\n","games":["Swords & Quills"]},{"at":347823529,"author":"John Edvard","login":"johnedvard","gh":656024,"url":"https://reitgames.com","twitter":"ReitGames","text":"

Unfortunately, there’s an issue with the game being contained in a very small container, so it’s difficult to play it. I understand you only had a few days to create it, but it looks like it has potential.

\n","games":["Samurai Sam"]},{"at":347856442,"author":"Thiago Romão Barcala","login":"thiagorb","gh":821208,"text":"

It feels like this would be a great game, but I couldn’t find more to do besides building things. The Job assignment doesn’t seem to be working. It took me quite some time to realize I could collect the trees and stones with the “remove” button. Maybe it would have been cool to just start without any resources in the bag, and then collect the resources to build something.

\n","games":["Duelo"]},{"at":348116054,"author":"João Lopes","login":"lopis","gh":2715751,"url":"www.jlopes.dev","text":"

Alright, this looks really cute and has lots of potential. The controls are a bit confusing, as usually in this kind of games, you don’t need to click “move here”, you just click, and that’s where they go. There’s many confusing things in the UI, like it’s not clear why I’m earning money (the buildings?) and I can’t seem to assign jobs to the villagers. And I guess you planned on having battles in the future, but that doesn’t seem to happen yet.\nGreat job on all the pixel art.\nAs you said yourself, the game seems pretty incomplete, but I encourage you to continue and share it with us on slack once it’s a little more advanced.

\n","games":["Market Street Tycoon"]},{"at":348225744,"author":"Ryan Tyler","login":"tyler6699","gh":50468,"url":"https://carelesslabs.co.uk","text":"

Hope you come back next year and allow yourself more time, you have what could be a nice game.

\n

Graphics are fun and I was able to move about and build.

\n","games":["Fort Knight"]},{"typ":2,"at":348697966,"author":"Joep van Duinen","url":"https://poki.com","twitter":"joepvduinen","text":"

A bit hard to give feedback, given the game is not finished. You were on to something though, all the ingredients to create a fun game seem to be here. With idle games like these, balancing it usually the most important thing to keep players engaged and challenged.

\n

I hope you stil finish the title at some point in time.

\n

Good lukc!

\n"},{"typ":2,"at":348711108,"author":"Ania Kubów","login":"kubowania","gh":51362610,"url":"javascriptgames.online","twitter":"ania_kubow","text":"

For the limited time you were able to use to create this game I am very impressed! You can see a lot of thought went into what this game will be - so you can definitely see the potential. I also enjoyed the retro feel to the game. Can’t wait to see how you develop this game further!

\n"},{"at":348737717,"author":"Mefistofel","login":"mefist0fel","gh":1374506,"twitter":"Polar0cean","text":"

Well, interesting prototype, but of course there is no proper target here.\nJust a strategy/city building game proto

\n","games":["Castle wars"]},{"at":348742602,"author":"Jasper Renow-Clarke","login":"picosonic","gh":26137750,"twitter":"femtosonic","text":"

I like the concept of the game, and the graphics look good

\n

Unfortunately the game didn’t work for me

\n

I was able to click on several things and even drag trees and rocks around, but couldn’t get it to build anything or progress the game

\n","games":["Princess of Corinium"]},{"typ":2,"at":348822448,"author":"Frederic Kyung-jin Rezeau","login":"FredericRezeau","gh":5784508,"url":"https://kyungj.in","twitter":"FredericRezeau","text":"

This game would need more work to be completed but this is a promising start for an ambitious project.

\n

I think there is an issue with the names showing as undefined (although the description helps). Controls and UI could also be streamlined a bit more.

\n

Good start, welcome to the competition. Please continue working on this game.

\n"}],"results":{"theme":{"rank":119,"min":1.08,"score":2.45,"max":4.38},"innovation":{"rank":133,"min":1.12,"score":1.9,"max":4.43},"gameplay":{"rank":135,"min":1.24,"score":1.75,"max":4.34},"graphics":{"rank":106,"min":1.21,"score":2.6,"max":4.73},"audio":{"rank":111,"min":1,"score":1.2,"max":4.32},"controls":{"rank":140,"min":1.29,"score":1.7,"max":4.23},"primary":{"rank":135,"min":7.57,"score":11.6,"max":24.7},"label":"Overall"}}